Jeb Bush Wants to End Medicare Like Them All

Jeb BushMedicare is hated by conservative elites. And it was hated long before it even existed. In 1961, Ronald Reagan said, “We are going to spend our sunset years telling our children and our children’s children, what it once was like in America when men were free.” He was talking about what would become Medicare. It’s silly in a way, but also callous and hateful. Now, of course, conservative elites have a problem because the one group that consistantly votes for conservative candidates is totally dependent upon Medicare. They mostly have sunset years because of the medical care that Medicare provides. Although I will admit that many of them do spend a lot of time telling young people about how great things used to be.

The truth is that Medicare has a problem: it costs a lot. This fact is often used by conservatives to claim that Social Security is not sustainable. It’s nonsense, but fundamentally Medicare is not sustainable. But it is true that Medicare is not sustainable. This is because we pay about twice as much for the same medical care as people in other advanced countries like Canada, France, Germany, and Japan. Medical inflation seems to be slowing down. But if things don’t improve, no one will be able to afford healthcare in America. Now that’s an issue of freedom that Reagan ought to have been worried about.

But conservatives are not interested in dealing with Medicare problems reasonably. The truth is that the elderly would just be squeezed out of the private insurance market. And the one thing that would have any chance at all of stopping that would be Obamacare, which conservatives also want to destroy. There isn’t a lot of honest discussion about healthcare on the right. Conservatives just want to destroy any system that will actually cover people. And to be honest, I’m not sure why this is. It seems to be some kind of ideological gut reaction that is not based on anything rational.

Now the most “reasonable” man running for the Republican presidential nomination is Jeb Bush. And I just read in Think Progress, Jeb Bush Quietly Suggests “Phasing Out” Medicare. And it’s the same old thing: let’s keep Medicare for those who now have it but then get rid of it for those who will soon need it as much or more. Or to put it more bluntly: let’s keep Medicare for the people who currently vote Republican and screw over everyone else.

This is always phrased as something that we must do for fiscal reasons. We just can’t afford to fund Medicare! But there are two big things wrong with this. First is just that the costs are not going away. Older people will still need medical care. So the question is only and forever who is going to pay. Second is that benefits determine taxes. There is this bizarre idea that many politicians and pundits have that somehow you could get rid of Social Security benefits but just keep on collecting those payroll taxes.

Ideology trumps everything in the conservative movement. They don’t like Medicare because it is “socialized medicine.” That doesn’t mean that they actually know what socialized medicine is. (Medicare is actually socialized insurance, not socialized medicine.) It is just a conservative bogeyman. But the press really needs to do a better job of covering this stuff. Bush needs to be asked what he thinks should be done to help the elderly who won’t get Medicare. I know what Bush actually thinks: nothing. But it would at least be fun to hear him say what I know he would: buying insurance across state lines; tort reform; high deductible plans — the usual conservative answers to every healthcare problems that would, in fact, do little if anything to address the problems.

Update (24 July 2015 10:33 am)

I didn’t realize just how much Medicare spending had leveled off. This is from Paul Krugman. It shows that per patient Medicare costs in inflation adjusted dollars have stopped growing. Amazing.

Medicare Costs
This entry was posted in Politics by Frank Moraes. Bookmark the permalink.

About Frank Moraes

Frank Moraes is a freelance writer and editor online and in print. He is educated as a scientist with a PhD in Atmospheric Physics. He has worked in climate science, remote sensing, throughout the computer industry, and as a college physics instructor. Find out more at About Frank Moraes.

3 thoughts on “Jeb Bush Wants to End Medicare Like Them All

  1. I sometimes feel that liberals need to call conservative bluffs and respond to every austerity proposal by insisting that austerity falls on key conservative constituencies. Want to get rid of medicare? we get ride of it right now, for current retirees. Want to cut discretionary spending? Say good bye to air traffic controllers. Want to cut food stamps? Cut them the deepest in counties that use them the most. Live in a State that is an habitual recipient of Federal dollars? The IRS should impose a surcharge on your child tax credit and EITC.

    It sounds incredibly cruel but we need to show seniors, people in Appalachia, Family men in Oklahoma and business travelers that when you elect GOP lawmakers, when you cheer on spending cuts, when you demand austerity, get ready to pay a price. Very quickly, these people would realize that government does not just help those mythical and conniving black people in Detroit and Chicago and NYC.

    • I know what you mean. But unless you allow this to be carried out in policy, there’s always plausible deniability. I know lots of extreme conservatives on welfare, and whenever I point out that the people they support want to cut their benefits, it is always the same, “They wouldn’t cut my benefits — just the benefits of those people who don’t deserve them!” It’s remarkable. And conservatives are great at playing this game. I just went around with a commenter about calling David Frum out of his racism. The commenter claimed that I was the racist because I brought up race whereas Frum never did so explicitly. That, of course, goes along with the conservative idea that if we never talk about racism then it doesn’t exist. But we’ve seen this on a policy level where Republicans claim that the only way to save Social Security is to cut us. We who don’t want to cut Social Security are the real villains.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *