There continue to be major protests in Spain—one on Tuesday resulted in clashes with the police, ending in at least 22 arrests and 28 injuries. The people are rightly unhappy about the recent austerity deal. It’s very simple. The Spanish government—like most governments—has debt. Because they don’t have their own currency, potential lenders are concerned that Spain will default on this debt. Thus, interest rates on Spanish government bonds are ridiculously high (almost 7% a couple of months ago). This problem could easily be solved by the European Central Bank (ECB) guaranteeing the Spanish debt. But the ECB will only do this (more or less) in return for $50 billion in austerity—budget cuts and tax increases.
Here’s the reason that the people are angry: Spanish unemployment is almost 25%. These austerity measures will only make things worse. How do we know this? The last three years in Ireland, Italy, Greece, Portugal, United Kingdom, and Spain. Oh, and the United States. And John Maynard Keynes. And the Great Depression. You get the idea.
Austerity from Without!
The German government and the ECB have been pushing an idea that was really stupid 3 years ago but now is just loony: if these troubled economies slash the size of their governments, businesses will magically have “confidence” and start hiring. Paul Krugman has come up with the idea that these people believe in the “Confidence Fairy.” It’s kind of like the Tooth Fairy, but without the evidence to support it. Think: the Great Pumpkin. The Confidence Fairy will rise up out of the periphery giving a booming economy to all good countries.
As with most of economics, there are lots of feedbacks in these policies. Spain has to borrow money to support its debt, but because it doesn’t have its own currency, lender fears of default push up interest rates, and this in turn requires more borrowing. Cutting government spending causes the economy to shrink, the smaller economy provides fewer tax revenues, and this in turn makes more spending cuts necessary. The only way this works is if the Confidence Fairy makes an appearance. But just like in every year’s rerun of It’s the Great Pumpkin, Charlie Brown, she never does.
Here in the United States, most of the coverage on this issue is from the German perspective. It is highly moralistic. It goes like this: GIPSI (Greece, Ireland, Portugal, Spain, and Italy) borrowed too much money during the good times and so now they need to tighten their belts and tough out the recession. (25% unemployment!) The problem is that this is all wrong.
Economics is not a morality play. It doesn’t matter if GIPSI behaved badly before; their bad situation now is hurting everyone. But the fact of the matter is that of those 5 countries, only Greece’s government acted badly. Spain (and others) had a budget surplus going into this recession.
What happened was that banks in Germany (primarily) thought that the EU’s shared currency meant that loans to GIPSI were as safe as loans to Germany or France. When the recession hit and these countries had trouble paying their loans, the German bankers freaked out. Now, we’re supposed to wag a finger in the faces of GIPSI: “You shouldn’t have taken out those loans!” But somehow everyone seems to forget that it is the bankers and not the borrowers who are supposed to police the loans.
Rick Santelli and Moral Outrage
We’ve seen this same kind of thinking here in America. Rick Santelli famously started the Tea Party movement with his rant about how good people like him were being forced to pay for the bad loans other people took out. Even apart from all we know about predatory lending, this is a ridiculous contention. Parents know that if they allow it, their children will eat cookies to the point of illness. Similarly, bankers know that people want to borrow more than they can afford. Or at least they should know this.
Whether it is the Tea Party or the German government, there is no place for moralizing when cleaning up an economic mess. But of course, this idea worked half way. There was no moralizing about saving the banks. In fact, after saving them, nothing was done to stop them having to be saved in the future. But when it came to saving homes and jobs, well, those people got what they deserved.
The people in Spain are fighting back. I wish them well.
Democracy Now! has a good story about what’s going on in Spain from the people’s perspective. It contains some interesting reporting like the fact that after foreclosure and eviction, people are still held responsible for their loans. Wow.
Update (26 September 2012 9:24 pm)
If you look on Google News, you will see that almost all of the coverage of this story is about how it is affecting the stock market. Pathetic. The AP has a good piece, Spain counts cost of anti-austerity protest, that gives an overview of what is happening. Note: its claim that 26 of the injured were police is almost certainly propaganda. Of the 28 initially listed in the CNN report, only two were police.
Update (27 September 2012 7:01 pm)
Paul Krugman wrote about all this in today’s New York Times. It is worth reading the whole article, but I was struck by this:
You can see in these comments the danger of past German government demagoguery: now that the government may want to fix the situation, it feels constrained by the Frankenstein’s Monster that it’s created in the people.